How brokers actually make money

11 minutesLesson 2 of 6
Femi, the HustlCraft strategy mascot

Every broker earns money from your trading somehow. Understanding exactly how changes what you should be suspicious of, and what you should not be.

A quick disclosure

Elsewhere on this site we link to brokers and may earn a commission if you open an account. This lesson does not, on purpose.

Understanding how a broker earns money changes how you read everything else about it, so this explanation needed to be free of that particular incentive.

Two different ways to profit from your trade

Every broker charges something on every trade: a spread, a commission, or both. That part is the same everywhere, and it is not, by itself, a warning sign.

An A-book broker passes your trade through to the wider market or to a liquidity provider. It earns its markup or commission whether you win or lose, because your trade is matched against someone else out in the real market.

A B-book broker takes the other side of your trade itself. When you lose, that loss is closer to being the broker's own gain. When you win, the broker pays it out from its own book.

YouA-book brokerThe marketYour trade leaves the brokerYouB-book brokerYour trade stays with the broker
Femi, the HustlCraft strategy mascot
Femi's warning

Taking the other side of your trade is a real conflict of interest. It is not automatically fraud, and plenty of regulated firms do it as part of a normal business model. But it means the broker's incentives and yours are not always pointed the same way.

Why this affects you more than the label does

Many brokers run a mix: smaller or newer accounts might sit in the B-book, while larger or more consistently profitable accounts get passed to the A-book. The label on a company's marketing rarely tells you which one applies to you.

A broker regulated by a strong regulator, such as the UK's FCA or Australia's ASIC, has to follow specific rules around disclosure and capital under either model. That regulation matters more than which model a given trade sits in.

You usually cannot tell which book your own trades sit in just by reading a website. That is one more reason the checklist in the next lesson matters more than any marketing claim.

The picture to keep

A-book and B-book are like a shop that either sends your special order to the wholesaler, or fills it from its own back-room stock. Both are normal business. Only one of them means the shop profits directly when your order goes wrong.

PreviousNext: The broker red flag checklist