How the basket is weighted

12 minutesLesson 2 of 10
Femi, the HustlCraft strategy mascot

This is the lesson people skip, and it is the one that explains almost every odd thing an index does. Two baskets can hold the same companies and still tell you two different stories, because they count them differently.

Two ways to add up a basket

Back to the market basket. There are two honest ways to turn four items into one number, and they answer different questions.

The Dow Jones Industrial Average and the Nikkei 225 are price-weighted: they add share prices. The S&P 500, the FTSE 100 and the DAX 40 are market-value weighted: they count each company by its market value, which is its share price multiplied by the number of shares.

Most value-weighted indices go one step further and use only the shares actually available to buy, called the free-float. If a founder, a family or a government holds a large block that never trades, those shares are stripped out, so the company counts for less than its full size.

The same two companies, two very different answers

A basket of two companies

  1. Company A: share price NGN400, with 10 million shares in issue. Market value NGN4 billion.
  2. Company B: share price NGN20, with 500 million shares in issue. Market value NGN10 billion. B is the bigger company by some distance.
  3. Price-weighted: the basket adds 400 and 20, giving 420. A rise of 10 percent in A adds 40 to that sum. The same 10 percent rise in B adds 2.
  4. Market-value weighted: the basket totals NGN14 billion, so A carries about 29 percent of it and B carries about 71 percent. Now a 10 percent rise in B lifts the basket about 7 percent, and the same rise in A lifts it about 3 percent.

In the price-weighted basket, the smaller company has twenty times the pull of the bigger one, purely because its shares carry a higher sticker price. In the value-weighted basket, the bigger company leads, as most people would expect.

Pull on the totalPrice-weightedABValue-weightedABSame two companies, opposite answers

Trading carries risk and you can lose money.

Why this matters when you read a headline

A price-weighted index has a strange consequence: if a company splits its shares, the sticker price falls without the business changing at all, and the company's influence on the index falls with it. Providers adjust a divisor to keep the index level continuous across splits and membership changes, but the shift in influence is real. This is why the Dow can tell a different story on the same day as the S&P 500, even though many of the same companies sit in both.

IndexHow it countsWhich company pulls hardest
Dow Jones Industrial AveragePrice-weightedThe one with the highest share price
Nikkei 225Price-weightedThe one with the highest share price
S&P 500Free-float market valueThe largest company by tradable market value
FTSE 100Free-float market valueThe largest company by tradable market value
DAX 40Free-float market valueThe largest company by tradable market value
Nasdaq 100Market value with capsThe largest, but capped so no single name runs away with it

When a report says an index rose or fell, ask which basket and which counting rule before you draw a conclusion about the economy. A move of a few hundred points can be one heavyweight company moving, not a market changing its mind.

The picture to keep

In a price-weighted basket the most expensive single item swings the total more than the cheap ones do, even if the shop sells ten times more of the cheap one. Value weighting counts what the shop actually sells.

PreviousNext: Meet the majors