What an extreme suggests

This is where positioning gets interesting, and where it gets people into trouble. A crowded trade is real information. The timing of its unwind is not information at all.
Extreme means extreme for this market
There is no universal number that counts as extreme. A net long of 100,000 contracts is enormous in one contract and ordinary in another. Extreme means near the top or the bottom of this contract's own range, measured over the last year, or three years if you have the history to hand.
Read the picture slowly. The net climbs for weeks, reaches the band at the top of its own range, and then sits inside that band for months while price carries on drifting higher. The crowd was already full long before the move was finished. Anyone who treated the first touch of that band as a turn spent half a year on the wrong side of a trend.
What an extreme actually suggests
- Fewer traders are left to join. New money has to come from somewhere else for the move to keep going.
- A larger pile of positions exists that must eventually be closed, which is why unwinds from an extreme can be fast and ugly.
- The market is more sensitive to news that cuts against the crowd, because a lot of people need the same exit at the same time.
Now notice what none of those say. None of them say the move is over. None of them say when. An extreme raises the odds of a sharp move at some point, and gives you no clue at all about the date.
The honest warning
Extremes persist. A market can stay crowded through an entire trend, print a new extreme, and then a bigger one. Traders who treat a crowded reading as a turn signal spend the whole trend fighting it, and pay for the privilege in spreads, swaps and stopped-out trades every week.

Crowded is not the same as finished. A market can stay crowded for months, and a trader who keeps taking the other side because the room looks full can be wrong for far longer than the account can survive.
An extreme reading may raise your caution and lower your size. It does not move your stop, it does not give you an entry, and it never justifies a bigger position than your rules allow.
The picture to keep
A danfo at the park can look completely full and still take one more passenger, then another. Full tells you the ride will be uncomfortable, not that it is about to leave.