Who is in the photograph

11 minutesLesson 3 of 9
Femi, the HustlCraft strategy mascot

Three groups stand in that photograph, and each one is in the market for a completely different reason. Once you know why a group is there, its position stops looking like a prediction and starts looking like a job.

Commercials: people with a business need

Commercials are hedgers. They are in the futures market because of a real business, not because of a view on price. A cocoa exporter in Ondo who will be paid in dollars in three months. An airline that already knows how much fuel it will burn next year. A manufacturer in Lagos that must pay a European supplier at the end of the quarter.

Their futures position exists to cancel a risk they are already carrying somewhere else. That is why the group often leans against price. As a currency rises, the exporter locks in more of it, so the commercial net position gets shorter while price climbs.

A commercial selling into a rising market is not calling a top. It is a business fixing a price it can live with. It looks like a forecast and it is not one.

Large speculators: the funds

Non-commercials, usually called large speculators, are funds and other large traders holding positions above the commission's reporting level and holding them for profit alone. No cocoa, no aeroplanes, no supplier to pay. This is the group most retail traders watch, and it is the group whose net position moves with the trend.

Funds tend to follow trends rather than call turns. Their net position usually grows as a move matures, which means it is often at its largest late in the move rather than at the start of it.

Small traders: the non-reportable line

Everyone whose position sits below the reporting level is added into one line called non-reportable. Nobody in it is named or split out. It is a mixed bag: small speculators, small businesses, and traders like you, if you traded futures at that size.

You will meet people online who treat this line as guaranteed wrong money, the crowd to fade. Be careful with that story. Size does not decide who is right, the group has no single motive, and the line is really just a leftover: whatever was not big enough to report.

Early, late, and neither

GroupWhy they are in the marketWhat their position tends to show
CommercialsA business need to fix a pricePositions built against the move, often early and often uncomfortable for months
Large speculatorsProfit from a viewPositions that grow with the trend, often heaviest near the end of it
Small tradersA mix of reasons, none of them visibleA leftover line, useful for balance, weak as a story on its own

Two honest words about early and late. Early is not the same as right. A commercial can be net short for six months while price keeps climbing, and that is a perfectly good outcome for them, because the position is insurance for a business, not a bet on direction.

Late is not the same as wrong. Funds are late by design. A trend follower can only be in a trend after it has started, and being in the middle of a long move is a living, not a mistake.

So the useful reading is never "the commercials are short, therefore price falls". It is closer to "the hedgers have been selling into this for weeks and the funds are still building, so this move is crowded and mature". One is a call. The other is context.

The picture to keep

Three groups in the same photograph: the shopkeeper protecting a price she has to live with, the speculator riding the move for as long as it runs, and the crowd at the back that nobody counted one by one.

PreviousNext: Reading a currency entry, line by line