Why a backtest and a demo mislead you

15 minutesLesson 4 of 5
Femi, the HustlCraft strategy mascot

A smooth line on a backtest or a demo account can hide the exact problem you just learned about. Here is how.

What a backtest usually assumes

Most backtesting software fills every trade at the exact price shown on the chart, with no spread, no commission, and no slippage unless it is specifically modeled in.

That produces a curve that looks smoother and more profitable than anything a live account will show, even when the entry and exit logic is identical.

What a demo account usually hides

A demo account often connects to a different, faster execution path than a live account on the same broker, because nothing real is at risk on the other side of the trade.

Fills can be cleaner, and slippage during news can be smaller or absent, which flatters a strategy that has never had to survive real conditions.

23.9 basis points a day was the average net-of-fees loss of Taiwanese stock day traders, measured across 3.7 billion transactions from 1992 to 2006 Barber, Lee, Liu, Odean and Zhang (2020), 'Learning, Fast or Slow', Review of Asset Pricing Studies

Live results, measured net of realistic costs, are the number that matters. A smoothed backtest line or an easy demo run is not.

Trading carries risk and you can lose money.

How to test in a way that will not lie to you

Before trusting any backtest or demo result, add an estimate of spread, commission, slippage and swap into the test, even if the software's default is zero.

If a strategy's edge cannot survive a deliberately pessimistic set of costs, it is unlikely to survive contact with a live account either.

Femi, the HustlCraft strategy mascot
Femi's warning

A demo account that never loses money to slippage is not proof of a good strategy. It is proof of a demo account. The bill for confusing the two only ever arrives on the live account.

The picture to keep

A backtest without real costs is like rehearsing a play with no audience and no costume changes. A smooth rehearsal does not guarantee a smooth opening night.

PreviousNext: Naira reality