Risk sentiment: calm days and frightened days

Some days the market is not trading a number at all. It is trading a mood. When people are calm, money goes looking for a return. When people are frightened, money runs for shelter, and it always runs to the same few places.
Risk on, risk off
When investors are confident, they buy what pays more and can fall further: shares, higher-yielding currencies, emerging markets. When they are frightened, they sell those and buy whatever they treat as shelter.
Traders call the two states risk on and risk off. Neither is a forecast. They are descriptions of what is happening now, and they can flip inside an afternoon on a headline nobody had on a calendar.
Where the money goes
| Market | When the world is calm | When the world is frightened |
|---|---|---|
| Japanese yen | Tends to soften | Tends to be bought, and bought hard |
| Swiss franc | Tends to soften | Tends to be bought |
| US dollar | Mixed, often softer | Usually bought, because the world's cash sits in dollars |
| Australian and New Zealand dollars | Tend to be bought | Usually sold first and fastest |
| Gold | Often drifts | Usually bought |
| Share indices | Usually higher | Usually lower, and quickly |
The yen and the franc behave this way for a structural reason. Both countries have long held large amounts of foreign assets and paid low interest rates at home, so money is borrowed cheaply in those currencies and put to work elsewhere. In a fright, that borrowing is repaid, and the buying required to repay it lifts the currency.
Part One described that unwind in interest rate differentials and carry. This is what the unwind looks like on a chart.
Where to read the mood before your pair shows it
- Share indices. The S&P 500, the DAX 40 and the Nikkei 225 usually show the mood before a currency chart does.
- The Cboe Volatility Index, usually called the VIX, which rises when people are paying up for protection.
- Government bond yields. In a fright, money buys government bonds, and heavy buying pushes their yields down.
- AUD/JPY. It pairs the most risk-sensitive major with the classic shelter, which makes it about as clean a mood gauge as a retail platform offers.
None of these are signals. They are context. Knowing that AUD/JPY is falling hard tells you what kind of day it is. It does not tell you where to place an order.
Shock events have no calendar entry
Everything else in this module is scheduled. Risk events are the exception. A conflict, a bank in trouble, an election result nobody had priced, a disaster, a policy announcement out of nowhere: they arrive when they arrive.
Two things make them different in kind from a scheduled release. Price gaps instead of travelling, so a stop does not fill where it sits. And they often land overnight or at a weekend, when your platform is closed and your position is not.

A scheduled release you can plan around. A shock you cannot. That is the whole argument for keeping your position size somewhere a gap against you is survivable, and for asking yourself every Friday whether you want to be holding anything at all across the weekend.
The picture to keep
Risk sentiment is the weather over every market town at once. On a bright day the traders spread out to the far markets where the margins are better. When the storm comes, everybody runs to the same three shelters, and the roads to those shelters jam.