Risk of ruin

13 minutesLesson 5 of 7
Femi, the HustlCraft strategy mascot

This lesson is where the last three lessons meet. A real edge and a real account can still end badly, and the reason is always the same one.

What risk of ruin actually means

Risk of ruin is the chance that a losing streak wipes out an account before its edge has had enough trades to actually show up, even when the edge itself is genuine.

A weighted coin still lands against you several times in a row sometimes. Risk of ruin asks one question: does the account survive that stretch, or does it end there?

How likely a losing streak actually is

The chance of a run of losses in a row is the loss rate multiplied by itself once for every trade in the run. A plan that loses 45 percent of the time has a 0.45 chance of one loss, and that same 0.45 multiplied by itself five times over for five in a row.

Losses in a rowChance at a 45 percent loss rate
3 in a rowabout 9.1 percent
5 in a rowabout 1.8 percent
8 in a rowabout 0.17 percent
10 in a rowabout 0.03 percent

A small chance is not a zero chance. Across hundreds of trades a five-loss run is close to certain to turn up at some point, which is why the account has to be sized to survive one rather than sized hoping it never arrives.

Trading carries risk and you can lose money.

The same edge, two different endings

This is an illustration of the arithmetic, not a promise of any particular result. The strategy and its win rate are held fixed. Only the size of each trade changes.

A 52 percent win rate, two risk settings

  1. Same strategy both times: a 52 percent win rate at 1-to-1 reward-to-risk, the same sequence of wins and losses.
  2. Setting one: 1 percent of the account risked on every trade.
  3. Setting two: 10 percent of the account risked on every trade, nothing else changed.
  4. Both accounts hit the same run of losing trades partway through the sequence.

At 1 percent risk, the losing run costs a manageable slice of the account and the edge still has room to play out over the trades that follow. At 10 percent risk, the same losing run is close to fatal, and there may be too little account left for the edge to ever show itself. Same strategy, opposite ending, because of position size alone.

1% risk10% risk

Trading carries risk and you can lose money.

Why thinner edges are more fragile

A barely-there edge needs many trades before its lean actually shows up in the results. A single large loss early on can end the test before the edge ever gets that chance.

44 percent of Taiwanese day traders in a large exchange-wide study were still trading after one year, falling to 24 percent after two years and 15 percent after three Barber, Lee, Liu, Odean and Zhang (2020), 'Learning, Fast or Slow', Review of Asset Pricing Studies

Survival, not one lucky month, is the first thing risk of ruin is actually measuring.

Trading carries risk and you can lose money.

Where this turns dangerous

Femi, the HustlCraft strategy mascot
Femi's warning

Revenge trading after a loss, raising the size of the very next trade to feel better about it, raises risk of ruin at exactly the moment it is already highest. It is the worst possible time to make that trade bigger.

The picture to keep

Risk of ruin is the chance the shop closes for good before enough cups of rice have been sold to prove the margin was ever real.

PreviousNext: Why risk management separates the survivors