What thin liquidity looks like

12 minutesLesson 6 of 8
Femi, the HustlCraft strategy mascot

The same lorry, the same instruction, two different mornings. One morning the market is full and the price barely notices him. The other morning half the stalls are shut, and the price runs away from him before he has filled the first row. The lorry did not change. The board did.

Thick and thin, side by side

Part One described liquidity as how much can be bought or sold without moving the price much. On the board, that is simply how many bags are pinned on each rung, and how many rungs have anybody on them at all. A thick book has long bars on every rung. A thin book has short bars, with gaps where nobody has pinned anything.

Thick bookThin book1,5501,5401,5301,5201,5101,5501,5401,5301,5201,510nobodynobodysame buysame buySame buy, different board

The buy on the left clears part of one rung and stops. The buy on the right clears everything at 1,510, finds nobody at 1,520, clears the little that exists at 1,530, finds nobody at 1,540, and is finally done somewhere above 1,550. The candle beneath is tall not because buyers were excited, but because there was nothing to slow them down.

Why price jumps in a straight line

An empty rung cannot be traded at. If nobody has pinned 1,520 and nobody has pinned 1,540, then no bag will ever change hands at those prices, and the chart simply skips them. On a candle chart that skipped stretch is a long body with no pause in it, or a wick that shoots out and comes straight back, or, at the open after a weekend, a gap where one candle ends and the next begins somewhere else entirely.

A stop loss placed inside an empty stretch of the board does not protect you at the price you wrote. It becomes a market order at the first rung that has anybody on it, which may be a long way past your number.

When the board is thin

The board thins out at predictable times, and Part One's sessions lesson already named most of them. Between the New York close and the Tokyo open, which is late evening in Lagos, most of the people who pin prices have gone home. Around a major release the pins are pulled for a minute or two. On a public holiday in London or New York, the busiest pinners are absent all day. In a small or exotic pair the board is thin at the best of times.

MomentWhat the board looks likeWhat the chart does
London and New York overlapThick on both sidesMoves are smoother, spreads tight
Late evening Lagos timeThin, many empty rungsSudden jumps on little volume, wide spread
Seconds around a releasePins pulled from the middleSpread balloons, price leaps through empty rungs
Exotic pair, any hourSparseJumpy, slippage the rule not the exception

None of this tells you which way price will go. It tells you how far a given push will travel, which is a different and more useful thing to know when you are placing a stop.

The picture to keep

On a morning when half the stalls are shut, the lorry clears each row in one bite and finds the next row empty. The price runs up the ladder not because the buyer is eager, but because nobody is standing in his way.

PreviousNext: Stop orders are hidden market orders