Drawdown maths, revisited hard

13 minutesLesson 7 of 8
Femi, the HustlCraft strategy mascot

You met this arithmetic in Part One. This time we go further, because the number that ends most accounts is not the losing trade. It is the decision made at the bottom of the hole.

The recovery table

A loss and the gain that undoes it are not the same size. The formula is simple: gain needed equals the loss divided by what is left. Lose 20 percent and you have 80 percent left, so you need 20 divided by 80, which is a 25 percent gain to get back to where you were. Part One showed the shape. Here is the full table.

Loss from peakWhat is leftGain needed to recover
5 percent95 percent5.3 percent
10 percent90 percent11.1 percent
15 percent85 percent17.6 percent
20 percent80 percent25 percent
30 percent70 percent42.9 percent
40 percent60 percent66.7 percent
50 percent50 percent100 percent
60 percent40 percent150 percent
75 percent25 percent300 percent

Down to about 10 percent the gain needed is close to the loss. After 20 percent it pulls away. After 50 percent the account needs to double just to get back to zero progress. That bend is what makes a deep hole a trap.

Trading carries risk and you can lose money.

How the dials in this module feed the hole

Every lesson so far is about keeping the hole shallow. A hope-sized stop, three correlated trades, 8 percent heat and a weekend gap can together produce a 15 percent drawdown from a single bad day, with every individual trade inside the one percent rule. The recovery table then charges 17.6 percent to get back.

The same losing streak at two risk levels

  1. Account NGN500,000. Eight losses in a row, which any real edge will produce eventually.
  2. At 1 percent per trade, compounding down: about 7.7 percent drawdown, roughly NGN38,600. Gain needed to recover: about 8.4 percent.
  3. At 3 percent per trade: about 21.6 percent drawdown, roughly NGN108,000. Gain needed to recover: about 27.6 percent.

Tripling the risk per trade nearly tripled the hole and more than tripled the climb out. The streak was the same. Only the sizing changed.

Trading carries risk and you can lose money.

The trap at the bottom

At the bottom of a drawdown two things happen at once. The gain needed is at its largest, and the temptation to size up to get it back is at its strongest. Sizing up at that point is the recovery trap: if the next trades lose too, the hole deepens exactly where the table is steepest.

  1. Set a drawdown level in advance at which size is cut, for example halving risk per trade after a 10 percent drawdown.
  2. Set a deeper level at which trading stops for a review, for example 20 percent.
  3. Only return to full size once the account has climbed back above the first level.

This is the opposite of what feels natural. Cutting size in a drawdown makes the climb slower, and it also makes the trap shallower. Slow and out beats fast and deeper.

Femi, the HustlCraft strategy mascot
Femi's warning

The recovery trap is not a beginner's mistake. It catches experienced traders because it feels like courage. Cutting size at the bottom is the courage that keeps the account alive.

Trading carries risk and you can lose money.

The picture to keep

A danfo in a shallow ditch is pushed out by the passengers. A danfo in a deep one needs a tow, and every attempt to rev out of it digs the wheels in further.

PreviousNext: Weighing risk on a prop account