Forecast, actual and the surprise

12 minutesLesson 2 of 7
Femi, the HustlCraft strategy mascot

Every calendar row carries three numbers, and most people only ever look at one of them. The one they look at is the least useful of the three.

Three numbers on every calendar row

Part One taught you to read a calendar and respect the moment. This module goes inside the row. Every entry carries three figures, and each one has a different job.

NumberWhat it isWhat it is for
PreviousThe figure published last time, sometimes revised at the same moment the new one landsThe starting point everyone has been comparing against
ForecastThe consensus of economists surveyed before the release, usually the median of the surveyThe guess the market has already bought or sold
ActualThe figure the statistics office publishes at the scheduled minuteThe only genuinely new information in the room

The actual on its own tells you nothing. Read next to the forecast, it tells you whether the room was right.

The surprise is the gap

Surprise is a plain subtraction: actual minus forecast. It has two properties that matter, and they do different work. Its direction says whether the number beat the guess or missed it. Its size says how badly the room had it wrong.

Inflation, year on yearForecast 3.2Actual 3.8the surprise0.6 abovecurrency bid

The grey bar is what the room agreed on. The orange bar is what arrived. Only the space between the two tops is new information, and only that space has to be repriced.

The same release, read two ways

One inflation report, two outcomes

  1. Forecast for annual inflation: 3.2 percent. Previous month: 3.1 percent.
  2. Case one, the actual prints 3.8 percent. The gap is 0.6 percentage points above the forecast, which is a wide miss for this series.
  3. Inflation running hotter than expected pushes the market to expect tighter policy from that central bank, and a currency with a higher expected rate path tends to attract money. The first reaction is usually the currency bid higher.
  4. Case two, the actual prints 2.6 percent. The gap is the same 0.6 percentage points, this time below the forecast.
  5. The case for tighter policy weakens, the expected rate path is marked lower, and the support under the currency goes with it. The first reaction is usually the currency sold.

Same release, same size of gap, opposite direction, opposite first reaction. Notice that the previous figure of 3.1 percent never entered the reasoning at all.

That is the whole method in this module: find the forecast, find the actual, work out the gap, then ask what the gap does to what the central bank is expected to do next. Lesson 3 takes that last step apart.

Trading carries risk and you can lose money.

Why the forecast is a marker, not a prediction

The consensus is a survey of bank economists, not a promise. Treat it as a marker of what has already been priced, and nothing more. There is often a second, unpublished figure too, the whisper number, the level traders privately expect. When a release lands exactly on the published consensus but away from the whisper, price can move as though it had missed.

The previous figure can also be revised at the very moment the new one is published. A strong actual paired with a heavy downward revision to last month can leave the overall picture unchanged, and price barely reacts. The revision is a surprise of its own.

Equal gaps do not produce equal moves. A release the market treats as high impact carries far more weight than a minor one, and the same gap means less in a series that jumps around every month than in one that barely moves.

The picture to keep

The forecast is the mark the class expected Ade to get. The actual is the mark on the list. Only the distance between the two changes how the room sees him.

PreviousNext: Interest rates are the engine