Reading a verified track record

12 minutesLesson 4 of 9
Femi, the HustlCraft strategy mascot

Verified is a good word and a small one. It means somebody read the account directly instead of taking a picture of it. It does not mean the account is safe, and this lesson is about the gap between those two things.

What verification actually is

A track record service connects to a trading account using the read-only password, the one MetaTrader calls the investor password. It can see the account but it cannot trade it. From that connection it publishes the closed trades, an equity curve, the deposits and withdrawals, the drawdown it measured, and the date its own tracking began.

That is a real improvement on a screenshot. The numbers were read by a third party from a live connection rather than typed by a seller. But everything it publishes is still a description of one account's past, and a great deal is left outside the frame.

What a verified page really provesWhat it never proves
These trades happened on this account, at these times and prices.That the program you are being sold placed them. A human can trade the same account by hand.
The account's own drawdown, as measured by the tracker.That the drawdown shown is the worst the strategy can produce. It is only the worst so far.
Money in and money out, flagged separately from profit.How many other accounts the same seller ran and quietly abandoned.
How long the tracker has been watching.How long the strategy has run in this exact form, since settings can change on any day.
Whether the account is live or demo, if the tracker discloses it.Whether it is a cent account, where the numbers look large and the money is small.

How a high win rate hides a grid

This is the single most useful thing a verified page can tell you, and it is never in the headline. A system that averages into losing positions closes almost every trade in profit, because it waits. The damage does not appear in closed trades at all. It appears in the gap between balance and equity, which is the money already lost on positions still open.

Two pages, the same monthly number

  1. Both accounts show a gain of about 4 percent a month over a year, and both are verified by the same tracker.
  2. Account A reports a maximum equity drawdown of 11 percent, an average win of 40,000 naira and an average loss of 55,000 naira.
  3. Account B reports a win rate of 97 percent, an average win of 9,000 naira, an average loss of 310,000 naira, and a maximum equity drawdown of 71 percent.

Account B is not a better system with a nervous month. Its shape says it wins small, waits out losers, and has already been within touching distance of the end once. The monthly headline was identical on both pages.

Read equity drawdown, never balance drawdown. Balance drawdown only counts losses that have been closed, which is exactly the number a system that refuses to close losers keeps flattering.

Trading carries risk and you can lose money.

The order to read a verified page in

  1. The tracking start date. A page opened three months ago describes three months, whatever the chart behind it stretches back to.
  2. Live or demo, and real or cent. Both are usually stated somewhere small.
  3. Deposits and withdrawals. A rising balance fed by fresh deposits is not a return.
  4. Maximum equity drawdown, and the date it happened.
  5. The trade list sorted by size. Lot sizes that climb after a loss are the subject of the next lesson.
  6. Average win against average loss, and the longest losing streak.
  7. Open positions right now, and how old they are. A position held open for weeks is a decision, not a delay.
  8. Whether the seller linked you to this page, or you found it yourself by searching the account number.

If most of those cannot be answered from the page in front of you, you have a marketing page with a badge on it, not a track record.

Femi, the HustlCraft strategy mascot
Femi's warning

A verified page is a receipt for the past, not a promise about the future. Read it the way you would read a receipt: for what it says exactly, not for the feeling it gives you.

The picture to keep

The papers on the car are real papers. They still do not tell you what the last owner did to the gearbox, and they are silent about the road ahead.

PreviousNext: Spotting dangerous mechanics