Spotting dangerous mechanics

12 minutesLesson 5 of 9
Femi, the HustlCraft strategy mascot

Four mechanics turn up again and again in the programs sold hardest. They are not secret and they are not always fraud. They simply share one shape, and once you have seen the shape you cannot unsee it.

The four, and what each one is doing

MechanicWhat it doesWhy it looks good for a long time
MartingaleIncreases position size after a loss, often doubling, until a win recovers the run.Every completed run ends in profit, so the closed trade list is almost all winners.
GridPlaces a ladder of orders at fixed distances and keeps adding as price moves against the first one.In a range it collects small profits repeatedly. A trend is what it cannot survive.
No hard stop lossPositions exit on profit, or on a margin call, and on nothing in between.No losing trade is ever recorded until the last one, so the record looks clean.
Averaging into losersAdds to a losing position to bring the average entry closer to price.It rescues most positions, which is exactly why the rare failure is so large.

Notice what they have in common. Each one converts many small wins into a debt that is paid in a single instalment. The account does not decline. It survives, survives, survives, and then ends.

The shape on a drawdown chart

Equitystartmany small wins, one at a timeone losing runTime

A normal strategy's chart is rough on the way up: it wins, it gives some back, it wins again, and the drawdowns are visible all the way along. The picture above is the opposite. It is unusually smooth, which is the tell, and then it is vertical.

Part One measured what that vertical section costs in drawdown and recovery. The arithmetic there is what makes this shape different in kind from an ordinary bad month, not just worse.

What doubling actually reaches

Eight losses in a row, doubling each time

  1. Trade one opens at 0.05 lots and loses. The next opens at 0.10, then 0.20, then 0.40.
  2. The fifth is 0.80 lots, the sixth 1.60, the seventh 3.20.
  3. The eighth trade in the run opens at 6.40 lots, which is 128 times the size of the first.

Eight losing trades in a row is not rare over a year of trading. The strategy does not need to be wrong often. It needs to be wrong eight times consecutively, once.

Ask one question and the answer decides everything: does the size of the next trade depend on the result of the last one? If yes, you are looking at a recovery mechanic, whatever the sales page calls it.

Spotting it when nobody tells you

None of this means every system with one of these mechanics must be refused on sight; the point is to know what you are buying. The exception is a seller who sells the missing stop as a feature: as claims that end the conversation said, "no stop loss needed" ends it there. Otherwise you are buying a strategy whose losses are not spread out, and whose worst case is the account rather than a bad week. Price that honestly, and size it accordingly, or leave it.

Femi, the HustlCraft strategy mascot
Femi's warning

A program that never closes a losing trade has not solved losing. It has only moved the loss to a place your account statement does not show it yet, and it will show it all at once.

The picture to keep

The car drives beautifully as long as the road is flat. Nobody mentioned that the brakes were removed to save weight, and you only find that out on the first hill.

PreviousNext: Questions to ask any seller