Questions to ask any seller

11 minutesLesson 6 of 9
Femi, the HustlCraft strategy mascot

You are not trying to catch anybody out. You are trying to find out whether the person selling you a program has ever thought carefully about the day it goes wrong. Nine questions do that, and they take one message to send.

The nine questions

Send them in writing, all together, in one message. Written answers can be reread when the program does something strange in month three, and a seller who will type an answer has already told you something about how the next year will go.

Ask thisA real answer contains
What is the maximum drawdown it has ever had, measured on equity?A number, a date, and the account it happened on. Not a range, not a target, not an estimate.
Over what period was it tested, and what was happening in that period?Start and end dates covering a fast market, a quiet range and at least one bad quarter.
Which broker, which symbol, and what spread and commission were assumed?The broker's name, the exact symbol string, and the cost assumptions in numbers.
Is there a hard stop loss on every trade, sitting at the broker?Yes or no, plainly, and if yes then whether the level is visible in the terminal.
Does the size of the next trade ever depend on the result of the last one?A direct no, or a direct yes with the multiplier and the maximum number of steps.
What happens in a fast market: a release, a gap, spread trebling?A described behaviour, such as a spread filter or a trading pause, not reassurance.
What happens if the terminal restarts or the connection drops mid position?How the program recovers what it was doing, and whether it can open a duplicate position.
How many live accounts run it now, and how old is the oldest one?Numbers, and a way to see one of them.
What are the refund terms, the update policy, and how do I reach you next month?Terms in writing, and a channel that is not only a group chat.

Two things to ask for as well as answers

  1. The exact settings file used to produce the results you were shown. Results from a different configuration than the one you receive are not results about your purchase.
  2. A demo, a trial or a rental period on your own terminal, at your own broker, before any payment that cannot be reversed.

Both requests are ordinary and cheap for an honest seller. Both are impossible for somebody selling a picture.

Reading the answer, not the tone

The friendliest replies are often the emptiest, and the driest ones are frequently the best. Judge the content of the sentence, not how warm it felt to receive.

Silence is an answer. So is a change of subject, a discount offered instead of a reply, and a sudden deadline on the price. Note it, and treat it as the answer to the question you actually asked.

Femi, the HustlCraft strategy mascot
Femi's warning

The questions are not rude and you do not need to apologise for them. Anybody who takes offence at being asked what happens on the worst day has told you they have not planned for the worst day, and it is your account, not theirs.

The picture to keep

Asking for the papers is not an accusation. It is what everybody who has ever bought a car in traffic and regretted it wishes they had done, before the money changed hands.

PreviousNext: Testing a bot yourself