How indices differ from forex

10 minutesLesson 8 of 10
Femi, the HustlCraft strategy mascot

Everything you learned in Part One still applies here. What changes is the ground it applies to. Take the habits across without checking them and the ground will teach you the differences the expensive way.

Set them side by side

A currency pairA stock index
What you are pricingOne country's money against another'sA basket of real companies, valued together
How many there areDozens of tradable pairsA handful that most platforms carry
Open hoursContinuous from Sunday evening to Friday eveningA cash session with a closing bell, plus extended hours on a futures-based quote
GapsMainly at the Sunday openEvery night, every weekend, and around holidays
Unit of movementA pip, defined the same way everywhereA point, worth whatever the contract says
The calendar you watchTwo central banks and two data sets per pairOne region's data and rates, plus four earnings seasons a year
Cost with no twin on the other sideSwap, which indices also haveDividend adjustments on price indices
Where the hidden risk sitsThe shared currency across several pairsThe shared economy across several baskets

Three things that catch forex traders out

One. Trends have a different engine

A currency pair is a relative price. Neither side grows: there is no such thing as the euro earning more money this year. A pair can drift for months, but it has no built-in reason to travel in one direction over decades.

An index sits on companies that reinvest profits and grow, and over long historical periods the major baskets have drifted upward as a result. Two warnings sit on that sentence. Long-run history says nothing about your holding period, and an index that has drifted upward for decades has also spent multi-year stretches falling hard. The engine is different; it is not a promise, and it is not a reason to hold something that is going against you.

Two. Sizing has to be done in money, not in lots

On a currency pair you can carry a rough sense of what a lot risks. On an index that sense is worthless, because the money per point differs by symbol. The only safe method is the one Part One taught: decide the money you are willing to lose, measure the distance to your stop in points, and let the arithmetic give you the size. Position sizing and the one percent rule is the method, and sizing off volatility is what stops you using a forex-sized stop on a market that moves differently.

Three. Company news moves the market

Four times a year the companies in the basket report their results, and in a value-weighted index the largest few can move the whole level on their own numbers. Nothing in forex behaves like this. A pair does not have a Tuesday evening where one firm's guidance rearranges the chart. It is also why an index can move sharply on a day with an empty economic calendar.

Fewer instruments is not the simplification it looks like

A small board sounds easier. You can genuinely know all six baskets, where a trader watching thirty pairs cannot. The catch is that a small board with nothing happening on it is where people invent activity, and the six are far more alike than thirty pairs are, which is the subject of the last lesson in this module.

None of this makes indices better or worse than forex. They are a different market with different mechanics. This module exists so you can tell the difference, not so you can switch.

The picture to keep

Same driver, same rules of the road, different vehicle. The danfo and the lorry both obey the traffic light, but you do not park them the same way.

PreviousNext: Where the fundamentals come from