What drives an index

Here is where a forex habit will trip you. You already know that a rate rise tends to lift a currency. Apply that same reflex to a stock index and you will read the screen backwards, because rates reach an index by a completely different road.
Four things move the basket
Strip away the commentary and an index level rests on four things. Everything you read in the financial news is a story about one of them.
| Driver | What it is | Where it shows up |
|---|---|---|
| Company earnings | What the companies in the basket actually make, and what they say they expect to make next | Earnings season, company results and guidance |
| Economic growth | Whether the home economy is expanding, which feeds through to sales | GDP, retail sales, PMI surveys |
| Interest rates | The rate at which future profits are valued today, and what borrowing costs the companies | Central bank decisions, inflation data, bond yields |
| Risk appetite | Whether money worldwide wants to hold risky assets this week or hide | Shocks, geopolitics, credit stress, a heavy fall in one market spreading to others |
Earnings and growth are the basket's contents. Rates and risk appetite are the weather outside the shop. A basket can be full of healthy companies and still fall for weeks because the weather turned.
The careful part: why rates hit an index differently
For a currency, an interest rate is the reward for holding the money itself. Raise the rate and, all else equal, more money wants to sit in that currency and earn it. That is the whole of the carry idea from Part One in interest rates and carry. The rate is a return on the currency.
A share is not money. It is a claim on a company's future profits. So the rate is not a reward for holding it, it is the yardstick those future profits are measured against, and it bites in three separate places.
- The discount. A profit arriving in five years is worth less to you today when a safe deposit pays more. Nothing about the company changed, but the price a buyer will pay today for those same future profits falls.
- The company's own bill. Higher rates raise what the companies pay on their borrowing, and they cool the spending of the customers those companies sell to. So the expected profits themselves get marked down, not just their present value.
- The alternative. When a government bond pays a decent rate, money no longer has to take company risk to earn something. Some of it leaves the basket for the bond.
Put the two together and one headline points two ways. A hot inflation print that pushes rate expectations up tends to firm the currency and tends to weigh on that country's index at the same moment. Same number, two screens, opposite colours. Interest rates are the engine covers the repricing itself.
Tends to is doing real work in that sentence. A rate rise that arrives because growth is unexpectedly strong can lift an index anyway, because the earnings side of the sum improved more than the discount side worsened. The channel is reliable. The outcome on any given day is not.
Risk appetite and earnings season
Risk appetite is the least measurable driver and often the loudest. When something frightens global money, the same behaviour repeats: indices fall together, the yen and the Swiss franc tend to firm, gold is bid. It is not about any one company's results. Part One's risk sentiment events covers the shape of these days.
Earnings season is the driver with no equivalent in forex. Four times a year the companies in the basket report, and in a value-weighted index a handful of the very largest names can move the whole level on their own results. A currency pair has no earnings season. An index has four, and they arrive on dates published months ahead by the companies themselves.
The picture to keep
Earnings and growth are what is in the basket. Rates and risk appetite are the weather. A rate rise is a reward for holding the money, and a heavier yardstick for the basket, which is why it can lift one and press the other on the same afternoon.